Navigation Menu+

Enlightenment quotes in the Declaration of Independence

A Postscript to Bentham's Critique of the Declaration of Independence

Jeremy_Bentham_by_Henry_William_Pickersgill_detailSoon after uploading Jeremy Bentham’s critique from the Promise of Independence, I acquired around to reading through the discussion within the New You are able to Occasions of Danielle Allen’s questioning from the period that seems soon after the language “life, liberty, and also the quest for happiness” within the official transcript from the Promise of Independence within the National Archives. Based on the Occasions, she sees this “errant place of ink” as resulting in a “routine but serious misunderstanding” from the Declaration. Here’s the way the Occasions summarizes her argument (a draft of her paper obtainable here):

The time produces the sense the listing of self-apparent facts finishes with the proper to “life, liberty and also the quest for happiness, ” she states. But because intended by Thomas Jefferson, she argues, what comes next is equally as important: the fundamental role of government authorities — “instituted among males, drawing their just forces in the consent from the governed” — in acquiring individuals privileges. “The logic from the sentence moves from the need for individual privileges to the significance of government like a tool for safeguarding individuals privileges, ” Ms. Allen stated. “You lose that connection once the period will get added.”

JohnLockeThe Occasions quotes Jack Rakove (whose volume Proclaiming Privileges may be worth talking to for individuals thinking about how terms of privileges were presented in run-to the only promise of privileges that People in america now bother to see) as mentioning that Allen’s work boosts a substantial problem on how to interpret the written text:

“Are the various components about the significance of government a part of one cumulative argument, or — as People in america have tended to see the document — subordinate to ‘life, liberty and also the quest for happiness’?” stated Jack Rakove, a historian at Stanford and part of the nation's Archives’ Founding Fathers Advisory Committee. “You might make the argument with no punctuation, but making clear it might help.”

At this time I believe that visitors of the blog are most likely thinking about, “what implications performs this have for Jeremy Bentham’s attack around the Promise of Independence?” Good question!

Related Posts